
Science and education relations between the Republic of Azerbaijan and Scandinavia and other Western European states — current issues
Ladies and gentlemen! Distinguished scholars!
Welcome to the First Forum of Azerbaijani Scientists Living Abroad!
As a member of the Board of Directors of the World Association of Azerbaijani Scientists (WAAS) and as representative for the EU, especially Northern European countries, on my own behalf and on behalf of our association I express my gratitude to the head of state, President Ilham Aliyev, who created these conditions for us. It is precisely on the basis of President Ilham Aliyev's wise policy and instructions that purposeful activity is being carried out today for the more organised development of the diaspora. I express my deep gratitude to the leadership of the State Committee on Diaspora Affairs of the Republic of Azerbaijan, headed by Mr Fuad Muradov, to the Ministry of Science and Education of the Republic of Azerbaijan, headed by Mr Emin Amrullayev, and also to the Forum Organising Committee and to the Chair of WAAS, world-renowned professor and fellow mathematician Mesud Afandiyev for their support of this forum.
Approximately two years ago, at a meeting organised in Istanbul with the initiative and support of the State Committee, we united around a concept and set out on a sacred path. I am confident that valuable and experienced scholars in this newly formed organisation will prepare and implement fruitful projects in science and education for our great homeland Azerbaijan. This is clear from the Charter drafted by WAAS and the ambitions put forward from the beginning.
I have lived in the Kingdom of Sweden since 2000 and from the first year received confirmation of the academic education I received in my homeland, proudly conducting scientific and pedagogical activity as a scholar in the Swedish science and education system and representing Azerbaijan. Since 2007, Azerbaijani students have studied in Europe, including Sweden, thanks to the ERASMUS+ programme and cooperation among the European Commission, EACEA, EU staff and the Azerbaijani state. Continuation of education for Azerbaijani students and scholars at European higher education institutions within various programmes is a very significant event.
Dear forum participants! As you know, EU–Azerbaijan relations are based on the EU–Azerbaijan Partnership and Cooperation Agreement in force since 1999. Negotiations on a new and improved framework agreement intended to reflect the broad spectrum of EU–Azerbaijan cooperation, strengthen political dialogue in key sectors and increase trade are at an advanced stage. For more than 30 years, students and staff have moved between European universities under the ERASMUS programme. Since 2015, ERASMUS+ has also allowed short-term mobility to Europe for students, researchers and staff from other parts of the world. This bilateral mobility enables students to study at a foreign university for 3–12 months and obtain credits recognised as part of their degree at the sending institution. Internships have also been possible since 2018. Grants are also provided for staff mobility of 5–60 days. Azerbaijani students and doctoral candidates, as well as the New ERASMUS+ programme for 2014–2020 in education, training, youth and sport, have helped define international higher education standards. This is both an indicator of our country's great potential and a sign of new potential opening up for Azerbaijan!
More than 2,000 university students and education workers from Azerbaijan gained the opportunity to study or teach in Europe under the ERASMUS+ exchange programme between 2015 and 2020, and 62 Azerbaijani students received scholarships for master's study during the period mentioned. ERASMUS+ provides support for internships and work placements abroad for bachelor's, master's and doctoral students, including recent graduates (within one year of completing university). Between 2014 and 2020, nearly 4,000 young people and youth organisation workers from Azerbaijan participated in joint ERASMUS+ and youth projects (exchange, training, policy discussion, volunteering).
When it comes to education, I am proud to say that every year a large number of talented young Azerbaijanis study at Swedish universities, including through grants awarded by the Swedish Institute. The Swedish Alumni – Sweden–Azerbaijan Students and Graduates Network is already active and, like the Young European Ambassadors at EU level, plays an important role in bringing Sweden and Azerbaijan closer together in every respect. Programme-country institutions cooperate bilaterally with universities in Eastern Partnership countries and apply on behalf of their partners. Azerbaijan has participated in ERASMUS Mundus Joint Master Degrees (EMJMDs) funded by the European Union, covering tuition, travel and living allowances for master's students from around the world. Azerbaijan has also participated in ERASMUS+ Capacity Building in Higher Education (CBHE) projects lasting from two to three years, aimed at modernising and reforming higher education institutions, developing new curricula, improving governance and building links between higher education institutions and enterprises. They can also cooperate with national government bodies to prepare the ground for higher education reforms and address policy topics and issues.
Higher education in Sweden draws on long experience: Uppsala University, where Anders Celsius, inventor of the temperature scale you all know, also worked, was founded in 1477, and academic education has been active since the 17th century. The biologist Carl von Linné and other champions of the spirit of the Enlightenment transformed the education system through the creation of the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, the establishment of a chair in economics and special emphasis on the natural sciences. These forces were also behind the government that first appointed an education commission in a long series of efforts to reform the Swedish education system in 1745. In the 19th century the state began to finance universities and thus assumed responsibility for their governance. In the 19th century there were two universities, in Uppsala and Lund. Their activities were first regulated by the university statute of 1852, thereby transferring jurisdiction over universities from them to the state. Women were admitted to university education in 1873: Ellen Fries became the first woman physician in history in 1883.
Karolinska Institutet was founded in 1810; in 1861 it was granted the right to award the medical licentiate degree (med.lic) and in 1906 the right to award doctoral degrees. During this period the university and hospital merged, making Karolinska Institutet the first university hospital in Europe. Several universities were created in the 19th century: Stockholm University, Gothenburg University, Chalmers and KTH. In the early 20th century Umeå University, Luleå University, Karlstad University, Jönköping University, Örebro University, Mid Sweden University in Sundsvall, Södertörn University College, University of Borås and many others, business schools, agricultural schools and the Military Academy were established.
For this reason, cooperation with Swedish universities and benefiting from their experience is purposeful for us. When Azerbaijan State University of Economics (UNEC) planned in January 2022 to apply to the ERASMUS+ KA2 Capacity Building in Higher Education project, I was pleased that, at UNEC's request, I played a direct role in establishing cooperation between UNEC and KTH (Royal Institute of Technology) in Sweden, where I was then working, and in concluding a very large and comprehensive cooperation agreement. The project's aim is to increase academic staff potential in renewable energy sources (RES) and energy efficiency and to update existing curricula. As an energy country, Azerbaijan depends heavily on traditional energy sources, yet research shows that the country has large untapped RES potential. The main goal is to stimulate local human capital in RES and strengthen government–academia–industry cooperation through the project. In 2022, within the ERASMUS KA2 project, UNEC sought a partner university from an EU member state to join our proposal. They researched and found information about KTH (Royal Institute of Technology). They saw that KTH participates in the master's programme in Renewable Energy offered by KTH and four other European universities. The faculty of the School of Industrial Engineering and Management, Department of Energy Technology, is engaged in teaching and research in renewable resources.
Dear forum participants! I believe that thanks to the WAAS concept such examples, projects and successes of ours will be more numerous and more effective in the future.
Scientific research forms the foundation for building knowledge that underlies continuous development of society. To achieve the global goals set out in AGENDA 2030 for sustainable development, in our view research plays a central role (USA. About the Sustainable Development Goals. 2019.).
From an international perspective Sweden has for several years invested large resources in research and development. In 2017 total expenditure on scientific research and development in Sweden amounted to 3.3 percent of Gross Domestic Product (GDP). This means Sweden exceeds the EU's 3 percent target and is one of the OECD countries with the highest expenditure on scientific research and development relative to GDP.
Sweden is a country with a high proportion of researchers among the population. Together with other Scandinavian countries, approximately 0.75 percent of Sweden's population work as researchers. This can be compared with countries such as the Netherlands, Switzerland, the United Kingdom and Germany, where the corresponding figure is between 0.4 and 0.5 percent. Sweden also ranks highly in the proportion of scientific publications per capita.
In 2015–2017 approximately 1.6 published scientific articles per thousand inhabitants fell in Sweden. With this indicator Sweden ranks behind only Denmark and Switzerland but ahead of the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, the USA and Germany. Sweden is also characterised by great trust in knowledge and research, which is an important condition for research's ability to solve public problems. Conditions are therefore good for Sweden to be a leading research country internationally.
Distinguished scientists! Sweden's research system presents problems and ways forward for the research system of the future. Research is the starting point for knowledge that is fundamental to society's development, business competitiveness and meeting the social challenges the world faces. To achieve the goals we set, all research must maintain high quality, which means we must prioritise excellence. Whether strengthening the quality of Swedish research or creating the conditions for new leaps in knowledge, the integrity and freedom of the individual researcher is essential. At the same time, increasing transparency and having a basic consensus on good research practice are very important to maintain society's high trust in research and researchers.
The main goal of Sweden's research policy for a long time has been for Sweden to be one of the world's leading research and innovation countries and a leading knowledge nation. Today, with our state's support and call, the Republic of Azerbaijan shares the same goal! And we must participate closely in this work with all our strength! Of course, the starting point for both countries is that high-quality research, innovation and higher education substantially contribute to society's development and prosperity and to business competitiveness, and respond to the public challenges we face in Sweden, Azerbaijan and globally.
For many years Sweden has invested heavily in research and development with broad science and research expenditure relative to GDP. In international comparison Sweden also stands out for a high proportion of researchers and a high proportion of scientific publications per capita, and is a country with high trust in research. Based on these guiding principles, the Swedish Research Council has identified twelve points especially important for a world-class Swedish research system. My aim in voicing these points to you is to emphasise that they are also relevant for Azerbaijan.
1. Research driven by researcher initiative and free researchers: Free researchers and curiosity-driven research form the foundation of new knowledge, innovation and society's development. Support for free research must be strengthened to create conditions for society's long-term development and distributed on the basis of research quality assessed by experts in national or international competitions.
2. External funding and base funding: External funding is required to ensure development of Swedish research quality. The main purpose of base funding should be to provide the best researchers with better, longer-term and stable conditions. The interaction between base allocations and government external funding envisages a clear division of roles and a clear picture of how different funds are used.
3. Research infrastructure: Advanced research infrastructure is in many cases a prerequisite for conducting the highest-quality research. To improve access to research infrastructure, the Swedish Research Council must receive increased resources to maintain and strengthen its responsible role in prioritising, coordinating and funding research infrastructure.
4. Outstanding research environments: Good and creative research environments are an important factor for conducting high-quality research and linking research, education and the rest of society. Primary responsibility for creating a research environment lies with universities; external funding is an important complement. Universities should cooperate more broadly to create the best conditions for a strong research and teaching environment.
5. Strategic research initiatives: Strategic research initiatives are an important complement to curiosity-driven research. The government must create a new strategic research council tasked with proposing fields for strategic research efforts to the Swedish Research Council.
6. Evaluation and quality assurance: Evaluation of research results drives quality. For Swedish research to achieve the highest scientific quality, all research must be reviewed by experts. Evaluations by educational institutions and national actors must be conducted so that they complement one another.
7. Internationalisation: Participation of researchers in international cooperation and contexts at Swedish universities is very important for quality and development of Swedish research. Sweden must develop joint national strategies for internationalisation covering both education and research.
8. Career paths and mobility: Long-term quality development of Swedish research requires a functioning and clear system of career paths within universities and colleges. For this, more resources must be directed towards a recruitment system that takes into account finance, research, teaching services and mobility and is based on human dignity.
9. Gender equality: Quality of research is strengthened by an equal research system. To achieve this, responsibility of higher education institutions for promoting gender equality must be developed and, for example, reporting through tracking how base grants are distributed by gender.
10. Ethics in research, good research practice and misconduct: Ethics in research is the cornerstone of research conduct, quality and trustworthiness. Ethical review of research must function satisfactorily and similarly across all scientific fields and in international cooperation. A national code of conduct for good research practice should be created and awareness and knowledge regarding research ethics strengthened.
11. Open access: Transition to open access requires dialogue among actors in the research system at both national and international levels. Transition to open access in scientific publications must be implemented with attention to quality in publications and taking into account researchers' mandates. Success in transition to open access for research data requires a national strategy and increased resources.
12. Research communication: Need for scientifically grounded knowledge and understanding of the scientific process is increasing. Work on research communications must be strengthened and coordinated so that researchers, universities and research funders can complement one another. In addition, new infrastructures for transfer of knowledge that make it easier for researchers to communicate their research must be developed.
Of course, knowledge and research form the foundation for ensuring good economic development, future prosperity and sustainable well-being for our knowledge and research community. However! Nevertheless, we live in a period when the importance of knowledge and research is increasingly questioned – when the existence of so-called “alternative” facts is a recurring topic in social debate, and access to knowledge and information is personalised! This, in turn, affects society's trust in knowledge and science. To increase awareness of the role of research and what role it may play in the future, it is more important today than ever that research be conducted in open cooperation with the rest of society. Research conducted to answer this and to create a solid knowledge base for society's development must be characterised by high quality.
I wish you all success in the course of the forum and thank you for your attention!